The Old Guard 2: Hit or Flop, Ending, and Sequel Status

Five years after Andy and her immortal soldiers became a quarantine-era Netflix favorite, the sequel is finally here — and it’s landed in a strange spot: hugely watched, sharply criticized. The Old Guard 2 hit Netflix on July 2, 2025, and it drew a 27% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes within days of release.

Director: Victoria Mahoney ·
Writer: Greg Rucka ·
Release year: 2025 ·
Streaming: Netflix ·
Lead actor: Charlize Theron as Andy ·
First film release: 2020

Ten rows of context, one pattern: the production facts are clean, while the reception is split down the middle.

Is The Old Guard 2 hit or flop?

For a streaming release, “hit” and “flop” don’t mean what they mean at the box office. There are no ticket sales to count, so the two available measures are attention — how many people watched — and reception, which is what critics and audiences say afterward. The Old Guard 2 wins the first measure and loses the second.

Is The Old Guard a hit or flop?

• The 2020 original became the franchise’s foundation — strongly enough that the sequel’s release pushed the first film back into Netflix’s Top 10 (Tom’s Guide streaming reviews).
• The sequel reportedly launched with 37.5 million views and 66.8 million hours viewed in its debut window (CBR entertainment news).
• It reportedly entered Netflix’s Top 10 in 93 countries and ranked as the number-one film in 74 countries, including the United States, during its debut period (CBR entertainment news).
• Tom’s Guide reported it reached number one on Netflix’s global movie list shortly after release and, citing Forbes, ranked first in 87 countries (Tom’s Guide streaming reviews).

The reception side is colder. Metacritic scores the critics’ response at 44 out of 100 — a result the site categorizes as mixed or average — and its user score sits at 3.9 out of 10, labeled generally unfavorable (Metacritic review aggregator). Rotten Tomatoes follows the same shape: 27% from critics, 33% from audiences (Rotten Tomatoes review aggregator).

So: commercial hit, critical miss. By the only metrics a streaming release has, The Old Guard 2 is both.

When did The Old Guard 2 come out on Netflix?

• The premiere date was July 2, 2025 (Netflix official listing).
• That put the sequel roughly five years after the 2020 original (Tom’s Guide streaming reviews).
• The road there was long: reporting attributed the delay to industry strikes, reshoots, and internal changes at Netflix (Tom’s Guide streaming reviews).

Five years is a long gap for a franchise that lives or dies on cultural momentum, and the delay shows up in the film’s own tensions — it acts like a sequel that needed to arrive sooner, carrying more setup than payoff.

Who is in The Old Guard 2 cast?

• Charlize Theron returns as Andy, the immortal leader (Netflix official listing).
• Uma Thurman and Henry Golding join the ensemble (Netflix official listing).
• Greg Rucka, writer of the source comic, wrote the screenplay (Netflix official listing).

The pattern: the cast is a step up, the reception is a step back, and the overall result is a sequel that performed like a franchise-starter while reviewing like a franchise-stall.

Why did The Old Guard 2 fail?

Calling The Old Guard 2 a failure takes a definition first. It didn’t fail to find an audience — it failed, in the critics’ view, to justify its own run-time and its own ambition.

What is the Rotten Tomatoes score of The Old Guard 2?

• Critics’ score: 27% (Rotten Tomatoes review aggregator).
• Audience score: 33% (Rotten Tomatoes review aggregator).
• Metacritic: 44 out of 100 from 22 critic reviews, categorized as mixed or average (Metacritic review aggregator).
• Metacritic user score: 3.9 out of 10 from 96 ratings, categorized as generally unfavorable (Metacritic review aggregator).

What are The Old Guard 2 reviews saying?

• Blunt Mag’s review: the movie spends so much time setting up future installments that it feels long (Blunt Mag review).
• Film Focus Online’s review: an underwhelming sequel that still deepens the lore with action and heartfelt reunions (Film Focus Online review).
• Reddit’s r/ActionMovies thread: the story and acting were okay, but the action scenes were mostly weak (Reddit r/ActionMovies user).

The critical through-line is imbalance, not incompetence. Reviewers credited the cast and the mythology while faulting the pacing and the set pieces. A sequel that is “too much franchise, not enough film” is a familiar complaint — it stings more here because the original was a tightly focused debut.

The Old Guard 2 should not be called an objective flop: with no box office, there is no financial loss to measure, and the viewing data runs the other way. But “flop” doesn’t have to mean financial failure. For reviewers, a sequel that spends its run-time clearing a runway for the next installment counts as a creative failure by the standard the first movie set.

Is The Old Guard 2 worth watching?

A direct recommendation, with conditions: conditional yes. The sequel is the second chapter of a story rather than a stand-alone film, and how much you enjoy it depends almost entirely on what you want from it.

Is the movie The Old Guard worth watching?

• Watch it for the team dynamic and the lore expansion that Film Focus Online called the sequel’s strong suit (Film Focus Online review).
• Watch it for Theron’s return as Andy and the new energy Uma Thurman and Henry Golding add (Netflix official listing).
• Skip it if you’re an action-first viewer: critics broadly found the action scenes underwhelming (Rotten Tomatoes review aggregator).
• Skip it if you need a complete story: the ending is built as a launchpad, per multiple reviews (Rotten Tomatoes review aggregator).

For franchise-completionists, the math is simple: you already watched the first film, and the sequel’s mythology matters for whatever comes next. For casual viewers, the real question is whether two hours of franchise setup is a fair trade for the emotional payoffs in the middle.

What is The Old Guard 2 about?

Sequel to: The Old Guard (2020) ·
Director: Victoria Mahoney ·
Writer: Greg Rucka ·
Critical read: lore over action

The sequel continues Andy’s story. Theron returns at the center of the immortal team, and the cast expands with Uma Thurman and Henry Golding (Netflix official listing). The film deepens the franchise’s mythology, which critics said came at the cost of pacing and action quality (Rotten Tomatoes review aggregator).

What happens at the end of The Old Guard 2?

The final sequence does two things at once: it makes Nile’s place in the franchise explicit, and it opens the door for a third film. What it doesn’t do, according to critics, is give that ending room to breathe — much of the run-time is spent positioning what comes next.

Why is Nile the last immortal?

• The sequel positions Nile as the last immortal in its final stretch (Netflix official listing).
• The in-film explanation is light: review coverage suggests the movie sketches the rules rather than explains them (Rotten Tomatoes review aggregator).
• Comic-lore note: the source comics contain more detail on the immortals’ rules; the film leaves most of that for a possible sequel.

The honest answer to “why” is that the movie doesn’t fully say. It shows the outcome and implies the mechanism; the complete logic lives in the source comic, not in the film’s dialogue.

How old is Andy in The Old Guard?

Known: ancient ·
Known: thousands of years old ·
Not stated: exact year

• The films establish Andy has lived for thousands of years; they never attach a number to it (Netflix official listing).

That lack of a precise number isn’t a plot hole; it’s the character’s defining feature. Andy’s age is vast on purpose — old enough to be tired of war, young enough to keep fighting.

Does the ending set up The Old Guard 3?

• Structurally, yes: multiple reviews note the sequel spends significant time establishing future storylines (Rotten Tomatoes review aggregator).
• Officially, no: Netflix has not confirmed The Old Guard 3 (Netflix official listing).
• Setup is not a green light — a sequel ending that points to more is normal franchise behavior, not an announcement.

The ending’s job, as the reviews read it, was to make you want the next film. Whether that lands depends on your tolerance for sequels that treat themselves as bridges rather than destinations.

The catch: a bridge to nowhere is just a viewpoint. If Netflix greenlights the third film, the ending will look like the smartest scene in the movie; if not, it will age poorly.

Is The Old Guard 2 LGBTQ?

Short answer: yes — with the caveat that representation and genre are different questions. The Old Guard’s LGBTQ identity lives in its characters, not in its marketing category.

Which characters in The Old Guard are LGBTQ?

• Joe and Nicky, the same-sex couple introduced in the first film, are the franchise’s anchor LGBTQ relationship.
• The sequel keeps the same immortal ensemble, and reviews praising the team’s heartfelt reunions suggest that bond remains part of the story (Film Focus Online review).
• Genre check: The Old Guard 2 is an action film, not an LGBTQ-focused film. The relationship is woven into the ensemble; the plot belongs to the fight.

One distinction matters: an action movie can contain LGBTQ representation without being an LGBTQ-focused movie. The Old Guard 2 is the former — its same-sex couple is part of the team’s fabric, but the run-time belongs to the action plot, not to a romance arc.

Why this matters: for many fans, Joe and Nicky’s presence is why the first film became a comfort rewatch. The sequel’s role was never to center their love story — it was to keep the franchise’s inclusive thread present, which it does.

Is The Old Guard 3 confirmed?

Will Netflix have an Old Guard 3?

• No official confirmation exists in the available record; Netflix’s title page lists the sequel without an announced follow-up (Netflix official listing).
• The sequel’s ending and several reviews point to franchise ambitions, but those are signals, not a renewal (Rotten Tomatoes review aggregator).
• An official announcement would come through Netflix’s own channels first; until then, speculation is just speculation (Netflix official listing).

Is there going to be a season 3 of The Old Guard?

• No — The Old Guard is a film series, so the correct question is “third film,” not “third season.”
• The 2020 original and the 2025 sequel are movies; there is no episode structure to renew (Netflix official listing).
• A potential third installment would stream on Netflix, consistent with the first two (Netflix official listing).

The implication: the ending and the reviews make a third film feel likely, but “likely” is not “confirmed.” Netflix has the viewer data to justify a sequel; it hasn’t yet said the words.

The Old Guard 2 specs at a glance

Ten rows of production detail, one pattern: a sequel built for franchise longevity, with casting that outshines its current scoreboard.

The Old Guard 2: upsides and downsides

The Old Guard 2 timeline

• 2020 — The Old Guard premiered on Netflix and introduced Andy’s immortal team (Tom’s Guide streaming reviews).
• 2025 — The Old Guard 2 debuted on Netflix on July 2, directed by Victoria Mahoney (Netflix official listing).
• 2025 — Review coverage converged on underwhelming action and heavy franchise setup (Rotten Tomatoes review aggregator).
• 2025 — The original film returned to Netflix’s Top 10 after the sequel’s release, signaling renewed franchise interest (Tom’s Guide streaming reviews).

Also in the timeline, the production’s long road: the sequel’s release came roughly five years after the original, following delays attributed to industry strikes, reshoots, and internal changes at Netflix (Tom’s Guide streaming reviews).

The pattern: five years of delays, then a launch that fans showed up for and critics didn’t.

What’s confirmed and what’s still unclear

The Old Guard 2 reviews, in their own words

One quote captures the split: critical praise for craft, followed by a shrug about impact.

“More competent than thrilling.”

David Rooney, The Hollywood Reporter — via Tom’s Guide streaming reviews

Another review made the franchise-structure complaint explicit.

“The movie spends so much time setting up future installments that it feels long.”

Blunt Mag review

And the audience side of the ledger, from Reddit’s r/ActionMovies:

“The story and acting were okay, but the action scenes were mostly weak.”

Reddit r/ActionMovies user

The pattern in these voices: the franchise’s people are praised, the franchise’s pacing is blamed. That’s the signature of a sequel designed for the next chapter rather than for its own.

Summary

The Old Guard 2 is not a simple flop — it’s a sequel that won the streaming war and lost the critical argument. Netflix got the attention it wanted, and the reviews now carry the warning: audiences and critics alike noticed the franchise leaning on tomorrow instead of delivering today. Netflix now faces a decision: if a third film moves forward, it needs tighter pacing and action sequences that match the cast’s caliber — or the goodwill the original earned will be spent.

Related reading

• The Old Guard 2 Netflix 2025 sequel: hit or flop, and worth watching?
• The Old Guard 2 hits No.1 on Netflix

Frequently asked questions